What Happens After the “Buy Canadian” Surge? (Marketing Strategy)

Borrowed playbooks, buy-local surges, and building something that survives past the moment.

PIVOT!

Do you remember the great COVID pivot(s)?

I do—I was there. Hands-on, inside a variety of businesses. For three years straight, I was helping Canadian businesses reach new markets, build new sales systems and strategies, and manage big changes. For a lot of the businesses I worked with, the changes were so outside their founders’ comfort zones that I also became a bit of a business therapist, constantly reassuring and holding space for some big fears and feelings.

There was a very short window of reprieve before the US Administration started playing tariff chicken with its trade partners, and I found myself back in the trenches. Same story, different trigger: new markets, new sales systems, new methodologies. All at once, all under pressure.

So I know a thing or two about pivoting a business through mass disruption. And right now, I’m watching a very specific version of this play out across the Canadian small business landscape.

But what I’m not seeing is anybody talking about the part that actually matters: what happens after the sugar rush?

The Part (Almost) Everyone's Missing

How you react to disruption tells me everything about whether you actually have a business strategy, or whether you’ve just been coasting on luck and momentum and calling it a plan.

The biggest thing I’ve learned from being hands-on in well over fifty businesses through two major forced pivots: a LOT of businesses are only operational through sheer, dumb luck. And any disruption—whether that’s a jump in sales or a massive drop—throws everyone off their game because they don't know how to handle the change.

Right now, if you previously sold primarily to US customers and you’re pivoting toward a Canadian audience, you’re probably seeing a real and encouraging jump in sales. Especially if you’re participating in any of the national call-outs, or are actively advertising as a Canadian business. This is good!

Canadians are rallying hard to support homegrown businesses right now. We have gone beyond “elbows up”; the gloves are off and we’re fighting for our own.

But I need you to hear this clearly: that surge is not your market. It’s a moment. And it’s fleeting.

We’ve seen this pattern before. There’s a big ramp-up, a wave of goodwill-driven buying, and everyone leaning in to support local. Then, a month or two in, the economic reality sets back in. Your new customer starts feeling the pinch in their own pocketbook, and the “support Canadian businesses” energy starts to quietly recede.

The people still care, but the moment has passed. If they didn’t buy from you before, they will go back to not buying from you now.

Why Your US Playbook Won't Work in Canada

Canada and the US have a lot of similarities. On the surface, it’s easy to believe that our only difference is a border. But you couldn’t be more wrong—our differences have never been more on display than they are right now.

This is the mistake that I saw constantly during the COVID pivot, and the one that’s happening in real time right now: businesses that take the marketing strategy, the sales language, the funnel frameworks, and the ideal client profile that worked for their American audience, and they just… port it over.

The Canadian market is not the US market with a maple leaf slapped on it. You can’t just pour some maple syrup on your campaign and expect it to work.

1. Higher Skepticism and Sophistication

Generally speaking, Canadians are a more sophisticated and more skeptical audience. We do our research thoroughly before buying, even more so as the price tag climbs. Big, aggressive, fear-based sales tactics that might convert well in the US don’t land the same way here. Canadians tend to be slower and more methodical in their purchasing decisions.

Canadians will smell your bullshit claims before you even have a chance to attempt to validate them.

2. A Culture of Scrutinizing Claims

If you’ve ever had to figure out Canadian marketing regulations for yourself, you already know what I mean. The rules are intentionally vague. The guidance documents written to clarify the rules are, somehow, not much clearer. And if you get really confused and call someone in government regulations to ask directly, the honest answer you’ll get is usually some version of "it depends on your situation."

At first glance, it looks like a system designed to be obtuse and infuriating. But once you sit with it for a bit, you’ll start to notice what it’s actually doing: refusing to hand you a checklist you can hide behind. It forces you to actually think through what you’re claiming, who you’re claiming it to, and whether it holds up.

The US system, by comparison, seems to let you say almost anything and deal with the consequences later.

Canadian businesses that sell in Canada had to build a habit of scrutinizing their own claims before anyone else does. And Canadian consumers have absorbed the same instinct. We ask more questions. We look harder for the gap between what’s said and what’s actually true.

So when you show up with a marketing playbook built for a market that rewards bold, unqualified claims, you’re using a tone that we’ve been trained to mistrust.

3. Population Size and Buying Habits

There are simply fewer of us. Rounding our population up to 40.5 million, the US state of California alone holds 39.5 million.

Because there are fewer of us, we simply do not have the buying power to negotiate massive discounts, so we’re used to paying more than our US counterparts. That also means we tend to be more careful with our spending.

If you’re selling something at a premium price point, you cannot show up with commodity-level differentiation and expect the “support local” wave to carry you. When that wave recedes, why would someone keep buying your candles, t-shirts, or self-care items from three provinces away when they just found out there’s a local option three blocks from their house?

The Operational Trap Hiding Inside the Moment

Here’s where I’ve seen genuinely good businesses make a genuinely costly mistake: they look at the order volume from the goodwill surge and make long-term operational decisions based on it:

  • They over-purchase inventory.

  • They over-commit to materials, ingredients, or components.

  • They over-hire or make costly staffing decisions.

Then the wave recedes, the orders slow, and in 6 months, you’re sitting on inventory you can’t move at the price point you need to pay the staff you shouldn’t have hired.

So you discount. And once you start discounting because of supply, you’ve started the slide into commoditizing something that was never supposed to be a commodity in the first place.

Don’t make your distribution and purchasing decisions based on a support-driven influx of orders. That data point is not your baseline. It’s a spike, and spikes are, by definition, temporary.

What Actually Needs to Happen

If you’re navigating this pivot right now, marketing harder in the current “Buy Canadian” direction isn’t the solution. It’s building the thing that continues to hold up after the current stops pushing you forward.

  1. Build a Canadian-Specific Ideal Client Profile (ICP): Base it on real buying behavior and real values—not just "supports Canadian business."

  2. Design Canadian-Centric Sales Systems: Respect how Canadians actually buy, free from borrowed urgency tactics.

  3. Make Realistic Capacity Decisions: Base inventory and hiring on a sustainable demand curve rather than this month’s goodwill spike.

Ready to Build for Long-Term Stability?

If you know that this current sugar rush isn’t a strategy to build on, but you aren’t sure how to leverage it to build long-term stability, we should chat.

This is the moment to build the foundation underneath: the systems, the positioning, and the clarity that hold steady long after the wave has moved on. My entire focus is on getting you out of reactive scrambling and into something stable enough to survive the next disruption—because there will be a next one.

There always is.