Email List? What Email List?
On learning how to undo over a decade of online sales strategy and just write for the sake of writing.
There is no lead magnet on my website.
No opt-in offer.
No little pop-up asking for your email in exchange for a PDF.
If you go looking for way to subscribe to anything from me right now, you’ll find exactly one option: my Substack.
That’s the whole list. And it’s not even one I own.
This is not an oversight. It’s avoidance. I know it’s avoidance because I know exactly how to do the thing I’m not doing.
Deep Fried, Extra Crispy
Because before I was doing the work I do now, I was a funnel expert. Think Amy Porterfield, Russel Brunson, Marie Forleo, Jenna Kutcher. The whole world of big launches and evergreen sequences and perfectly engineered email sequences that moves someone from “just curious” to “buy now.”
My name was passed around a LOT in that world. I was the one you’d hire to build the system after you couldn’t make their DIY programs work.
And it burned me the hell out. Deep fried, extra crispy.
The entire model runs on one requirement: you must always be selling something new.
And that meant continuously creating new offers, new products, new launches, new reasons to get someone’s email address.
Because the machine needs fuel.
So when I decided to come back, I knew two things right away: I knew I didn’t want to be that person again. And I knew I had no idea what to do instead.
But that didn’t stop me from falling back into those patterns once again. When I soft-launched my comeback in the summer of 2025, it was with a refreshed version of some of the same offers I was running in 2021.
The Pitfall of Old Muscle Memory
Thankfully, I quickly changed my mind once I realized what I was doing. It took me six weeks to build everything out and start running paid ads, and one day (plus $5K in adspend) to realize that it was the wrong direction and tear it all down.
It took me a while - almost a whole year - to find the direction I’m currently pointing. But the one place I keep getting stuck is that email list.
Over and over and over again.
Because I already experienced how quickly the old muscle memory takes over. And how quickly something I create transforms from “this is what my clients need” to “this is what I can sell them next.”
And every time I sit down to write an email sequence, I can feel it trying take the lead. The urgency language, the scarcity framing, the “buy now” energy. It’s right there, sitting between me and the keyboard. Because I spent years training myself to write that way, and getting hired specifically because I was damn good at it.
When I walked away from my business in 2023, I had 24 offers and 42 lead magnets.
I could sell you something new every month for two years, and you’d never see the same thing twice.
Quality over Quantity: Where I Stand Now
Now, I have one offer, sold in three different containers depending on both my capacity and my clients’ needs.
While I do have a list subscribe form on my site now, there’s no lead magnet attached to it. Right now, if you sign up, you get exactly one welcome email and that’s it. I haven’t even written a follow-up email.
Because I haven’t figured out yet what I want it to be, I only know what I don’t. I don’t want it be something where I’m pushing out a different offer every week. I don’t want a content calendar mapped out a full year in advance with a “sell” slotted every fourth or fifth send. I don’t want people to dread seeing my name in their inbox.
I want it to be worthy of reading; and worthy of writing.
Replacing the System
I don’t have a resolution yet. I know the list needs to exist. I know it needs to be conversational instead of engineered, but I don’t yet know how to build it without engineering it.
But maybe that not-knowing is the actual point for now.
In order to let the old muscle memory atrophy, I have to replace it with a new system—one where I let myself write without knowing the twelve emails that come next or what I’m going to sell you in 3 months.
LATE OCTOBER 2026 UPDATE
At the time I wrote this, I really had no idea what I was going to do about the damn email list. But it seems the act of writing this gave me the answer. I send a twice-monthly newsletter-style email where I share practical, low-noise strategy or where you can find helpful tidbits - either from me, or from people I trust, and let you know what's going on in my world or what I'm working on. That's it. No sales flows, no sequences, no complicated funnels. If you appreciate raw thoughts on business without the engineered 12-part sales funnels, you can join my list over there. -->